When it comes to mid-size enterprises, the choice between managing marketing efforts in-house or enlisting the expertise of a marketing agency becomes a complex decision.

Chris Zulawski Avatar


ux developer and ui designer brainstorming about mobile app wireframe on an office table

Hiring a Marketing Agency vs. In-House Marketing: Navigating the Best Path for Mid-Size Enterprises

4 min read

When it comes to mid-size enterprises, the choice between managing marketing efforts in-house or enlisting the expertise of a marketing agency becomes a complex decision. As decision-makers within these enterprises grapple with this dilemma, the need to carefully weigh the pros and cons becomes increasingly clear. This exploration is not just about immediate gain but serves as a compass to guide the trajectory of business growth and market competitiveness.

Understanding In-House Marketing: A Double-Edged Sword

In-house marketing, often viewed as a beacon of control, comes with its own set of advantages. The ability to directly oversee and fine-tune marketing activities is viewed as a major benefit, as is the potential for fostering team alignment with the company’s unique culture. Cost savings, a significant appeal for mid-size enterprises, is another aspect where in-house marketing shines. However, this seemingly straightforward path is not without its share of challenges. The need for a diverse range of expertise, the allocation of resources, and the potential scalability hurdles pose significant obstacles for mid-size enterprises aiming for marketing self-sufficiency.

The Advantages of Hiring a Marketing Agency: Tapping into Specialized Excellence

Analyst working with Business Analytics and Data Management System on computer

On the opposite end of the spectrum lies the engagement of a marketing agency, a decision that introduces a new set of dynamics to the marketing landscape. The advantages are manifold. Having access to specialized skills is perhaps one of the most compelling reasons mid-size enterprises turn to marketing agencies. These entities, often housing diverse teams of experts, bring fresh perspectives and a wealth of experience to the table. Scalability, a challenge often faced by in-house teams, is addressed by the flexibility and adaptability that agencies offer. Beyond these, marketing agencies provide strategic insights and have the capability to deploy advanced tools and technologies that may not be readily available in-house, providing mid-size enterprises with a competitive edge in the dynamic market landscape.

Cost Considerations: Beyond the Bottom Line

Diving into the intricacies of the decision-making process requires a comprehensive analysis of the associated costs. It’s not merely about the bottom line; it’s about understanding the long-term value of either option. Staffing costs, technology investments, training expenses, and agency fees all contribute to the holistic financial picture. This comparative analysis becomes a roadmap, guiding decision-makers to understand the true costs of each option and make informed choices that align with the financial health and sustainability of their enterprise.

Success Stories: Learning from Real-World Experiences

digital business data graph showing increased and decreased trend lines

Real-world examples and case studies bring a practical dimension to this decision-making process of hiring a marketing agency vs. in-house marketing. These stories offer invaluable insights into the experiences of mid-size businesses that have chosen either in-house marketing or engaged the services of a marketing agency. Success stories illuminate the positive outcomes, showcasing how a well-executed in-house strategy or a strategic partnership with an agency can drive business growth. Simultaneously, lessons learned from challenges encountered provide a realistic perspective, helping decision-makers anticipate potential hurdles and make proactive decisions that align with their business objectives.

A perfect example of hiring a marketing agency came from a niche photography studio faced with a monthly loss of $14,000 despite having a stellar reputation and effective lead-generation tactics. The challenge prompted a strategic overhaul to refine pricing, enhance positioning, and optimize the sales strategy, leading to a transformative shift. Within the first 90 days, the studio not only achieved a $1 million profit but also secured recurring revenue accounts, earning 7x more profit within four months. This resulted in fully booked schedules and empowered creativity, setting the stage for continued exponential company growth.

On the other hand, Frootbat, an online liquor marketplace, transformed its business by strategically leveraging in-house marketing. Recognizing the need to diversify their keyword portfolio and gain visibility in competitive markets, they utilized Semrush data to replicate and surpass competitor strategies. Through a targeted SEO campaign, competitor keyword analysis, and ongoing monitoring with tools like Semrush EyeOn, Frootbat not only increased organic search traffic by 49% but also expanded product lines, projected a 2X revenue increase, and achieved significant success in a competitive industry.

Making the Right Choice for Your Business: A Tailored Approach

As mid-size enterprises stand at the crossroads, the key lies in assessing specific needs and resources. This involves a thorough evaluation of current marketing capabilities, the depth of team expertise, and the alignment of marketing strategies with long-term business objectives. The decision-making process becomes more than a binary choice; it becomes a tailored approach, considering the unique nuances of each enterprise. By leveraging this tailored approach, decision-makers can navigate through the complexities of the marketing landscape and make choices that align best with the unique characteristics of their business.

Empowering Mid-Size Enterprises for Success

Project manager working on updating tasks with milestones progress planning

In the dynamic realm of mid-size enterprises, the decision between hiring an agency or managing marketing in-house is a critical factor in shaping the trajectory of business growth. This exploration has taken us through the benefits and challenges of in-house marketing, the advantages of engaging a marketing agency, the financial considerations, real-world examples, and the guidance needed for informed decision-making. As decision-makers grapple with this multifaceted dilemma, the key takeaway is empowerment. By understanding the nuances, weighing the options, and learning from the experiences of others, decision-makers can chart a course that propels their enterprise toward success.

Schedule a Consultation for Personalized Guidance

As you navigate this decision-making process, we invite you to reach out to Zillas for a consultation or an audit. Our experts are eager and ready to provide personalized guidance tailored to the unique needs of your mid-size enterprise. Contact us today to explore how the right marketing strategy can drive your business towards new heights.

Chris Zulawski

Chris Zulawski Avatar


Get In Touch